Stained Red Chapter Eleven
Waking the next morning Natalie sighed out in relief finding that Taylor had somehow moved out and off of her during the night. Now that she was more clear headed she knew last night had been a mistake. A mistake that shouldn't have happened, wouldn't have happened if she had been sober.
Slowly she moved out of the bed, grabbing her clothes on the way. Once she was out of his room she slipped into the bathroom, knowing she needed to take a shower before she went to pick up the kids. She didn't want to pick them up smelling of sex. Smelling like Taylor.
Laying her clothes on the back of the toilet she bent over, turning the water on, waiting for it to get just right before she stepped in, closing her eyes as she relaxed some under the water. She hated that she let Taylor get in her pants again. Hated that she slept with him knowing he was Theo's father, knowing that deep down she was still in love with Isaac. Even if she knew they'd never get back together she still had some hope and if he knew she had slept with Taylor he'd never see her the same way again.
Though Isaac did sleep with Nikki so maybe if he found out he wouldn't judge her too bad. Maybe he wouldn't be so mad at her. Maybe that was all Natalie could hope for..a bunch of fucking maybe's.
Feeling a pair of hands on her naked hips, Natalie opened her eyes seeing Taylor with her in the shower, which caused her forehead to crinkle some in confusion. Was she still asleep? She wasn't sure why he was in the shower with her nor was she sure she liked the idea of him being in the shower with her, even if the shower was in his house.
Before she can say anything though Taylor leaned in to kiss her, making her breath catch in her throat. Now that she wasn't drunk she was surprised to find that maybe being drunk had nothing to do with what happened last night. Taylor lips did feel good on her own and she let herself respond to the kiss knowing it was risky. There was no excuse for this now. No blaming the alcohol.
Kissing him harder, she moaned out as Taylor pushed her back against the wall, his lips trailing down her neck which made her tilt her head to the side, "Taylor," she muttered out as she felt his hand reach down to lift up her leg and soon she felt him slide inside of her. "This..it's wrong," she told him though she wasn't sure she could make him stop.
"But it feels good," Taylor countered once he heard Natalie's words. "Last night was amazing," he whispered on her skin as he started to move inside of her. "I just...I don't want this to end," he confessed not caring that he was engaged to Nikki.Not caring that she was divorcing his brother. "Be my dirty secret?" he asked as his lips trailed to her ear which he nibbled on. This wouldn't be the first time he had an affair while in a relationship, though it would be the first time he had one while engaged.
Natalie heard Taylor ask her to be his dirty secret and she shook her head, "W..we can't," she voiced knowing that even though they were having sex again this had to be the last time. Anyway once the truth came out about Theodore, Taylor would hate her. He'd never want her and she still had hopes that she could work things out with Isaac...even if her vagina obviously wanted another Hanson.
Closing her eyes again though she let her nails dig into Taylor's back as he continued to move inside of her, obviously not trying to change her mind on not agreeing to be his dirty secret. She was glad for that because when she finally reached her orgasm she was sure he could have won her over if he had wanted too.
When he finally came she opened her eyes, watching as he moved away from her. Natalie was just about to open her mouth when she heard his front door open.
"Taylor!" Nikki's voice called out from downstairs, which made Natalie's eyes go wide as she watched Taylor freeze for a few seconds like a deer in headlights. Thought it didn't last long before he climbed out of the shower.
"I'll be there in a second baby," Taylor called out after slipping out of the shower. As he wrapped a towel around his waist he looked at Natalie before chewing on his lip. He hated to admit that he was kind of hurt that she had rejected his offer to have an affair, though he knew that was no reason to give away that she was here but that was going to happen.
Natalie would have to leave the bathroom too and Nikki would do the math, they were both screwed no matter what now. Not even saying a word to her though, he opened the door and slipped outside, going down the stairs.
After Taylor left her alone in the bathroom, Natalie frowned but got out as well, drying and dressing quickly. She wasn't sure what she would do when she saw Nikki but in all honesty Nikki had no right being mad about this. Not when Nikki had fucked Isaac..not when she was blackmailing Isaac.
Taking a deep breath once she was ready Natalie left the bathroom and headed downstairs where she found Nikki and Taylor in the middle of an argument, Nikki's glare soon turning to her.
"You fucking whore," Nikki spat as she walked over to Natalie. She knew who the woman was, she knew she was Isaac's wife. She also knew Natalie's past thanks to Isaac, just like she knew Natalie's secret. Though Natalie didn't know hers. Natalie was oblivious to her fucking Isaac as was Taylor. Nikki loved that she could play the scorned woman card all she wanted. "Did Taylor's brother not tell you we were engaged?" she asked as she raised an eyebrow before grabbing a hold of Natalie's wrist to stop her from leaving.
Making a face when Nikki grabbed her wrist, Natalie shook her head, "No, he didn't," she lied as she eyed Nikki. "I haven't seen him in a few weeks," she lied again not even feeling bad for her lies. "But Taylor did tell me himself you guys were engaged," she snapped back.
Nikki glared as she held Natalie's wrist tighter, "Yet you still fucked him," she said before rolling her eyes.
"Well actually he fucked me too," Natalie countered ignoring the pressure added when Nikki's grip got worse. "He fucked me too and he seemed to like it so much that he had to have it again in the shower," she smirked. She knew she should be feeling guilty but she just hated Nikki. She hated Nikki for what she was doing to Isaac.
"Don't you dare play that card," Nikki sneered as she raised her free hand slapping Natalie across the face hard.
Taylor winced as Nikki slapped Natalie and he walked over to both of them, grabbing Nikki's arm and pulling her away from Natalie, "Nikki baby calm down, you really shouldn't get too worked up okay. Don't press people's buttons not in your condition."
Holding her cheek, Natalie watched as Taylor lead Nikki away. "Her condition?" she asked as she raised an eyebrow.
"She's pregnant Natalie," Taylor confessed as he looked at her a frown appearing on his lips. "That's why she came back from her trip early. She just found out she is pregnant."
Natalie swallowed hard as she heard Taylor say Nikki was pregnant. All she could do was remember the night Isaac confessed to sleeping with Nikki. Feeling her face pale some she was afraid she was going to faint in Taylor's living room so she rested her hand against a wall to steady herself.
"That's great," Natalie nodded forcing a smile as she locked eyes with Nikki. "I have to go though now," she said as she removed her hand from the wall just wanting to get out of there fast. Without another word she finally got her feet to move and she left Taylor's house making it to where she had parked her car.
Getting in she put her keys in the ignition before reaching for the cell phone she had in a cup holder. Checking it she saw a text message from Isaac telling her they needed to meet up asap. A text message that had been sent just an hour ago.
Replying back she agreed, telling Isaac to meet her at the house. After sending the text she called Diana to tell her that she'd be picking up the kids sometime in the afternoon instead of the morning as she had planned to do.
Once she had hung up from speaking with Diana, Natalie finally started her car and drove away. When she finally made it home she parked behind Isaac's car. Getting out she walked to the porch and let herself inside where she found Isaac holding the paper with the DNA test results.
Natalie swallowed hard again having forgotten that she had left the papers on the coffee table. She hadn't wanted Isaac to find out this way. She hadn't wanted Isaac to find out on accident.
"Theo isn't mine?" Isaac asked as he looked up from the paper's he held in his hand. He had just gotten here not too long ago himself. He knew he shouldn't have but he let himself in with his old key. He also knew he shouldn't have picked up the paper but he did...he did and now he knew that Theodore the son he raised since birth wasn't his. Theodore belonged to Taylor.
Natalie shook her head sadly, "No...he isn't yours," she said shutting the door before walking to Isaac. "I..I found out yesterday but I needed a day to process things. I was going to tell you but I didn't want you to find out like this."
Laying the paper down on the table Isaac nodded, "I believe you," he said before sitting on the couch and laughing bitterly. "That was the last thing I needed today though after finding out Nikki is pregnant?"
"You know Nikki is pregnant?" Natalie asked as she sat down beside Isaac on the couch. "I mean she came back from a trip today. She just told Taylor.." Natalie started but stopped herself as a blush came onto her cheeks. She had probably said too much.
"How do you know Nikki is pregnant and how do you know she just told Taylor?" Isaac questioned his wife as he locked eyes with her, realization soon hitting him square in the face when he saw the blush on her cheeks and the guilt in her eyes.Natalie was like an open book to him by now when it came to her reactions. She knew because she had been there. She knew because she had been with Taylor when he had found out.
Natalie shrugged as she looked away from Isaac's gaze, "I..I was with him," she stuttered as she ran a hand through her hair. "I may have gotten drunk with him last night. We may have had sex last night when we were drunk and then again this morning in the shower. Nikki showed up after the shower sex. We had a confrontation and it came out about her condition as Taylor called it. When I asked he told me she was pregnant."
Closing his eyes at Natalie's words Isaac hated to admit that he was jealous she had been with Taylor. It was silly for him to be jealous when Natalie would soon no longer be his wife. Natalie was free to do as she pleased but it hurt knowing it was Taylor. It hurt knowing she had slept with the man who was the real father of the son he considered his. Though then again he considered Natalie his too still.
"Nikki says the baby could be mine," Isaac revealed deciding not to say anything about Natalie sleeping with Taylor. "But she wants me to let Taylor believe it's his. Seems she wants to be just like you," he said a little too harsh.
Natalie did her best to ignore Isaac's harsh tone, "Well when I tell Taylor the truth about Theo you won't have to worry about letting Taylor believe Nikki's baby is his. You can be honest with him."
Isaac just nodded his head not sure now if telling him about Nikki was a good thing, especially since Theo wasn't his son. Maybe they could just keep letting everyone believe that Theo was his and let Taylor believe fully that Nikki's child was his. Maybe that would be best. Or maybe he was just scared that he'd lose Theo and that Nikki's baby also wouldn't be his and then he'd have no one.
Hell he was already losing Natalie if she had so easily slept with Taylor twice in just twenty-four hours.
Waking the next morning Natalie sighed out in relief finding that Taylor had somehow moved out and off of her during the night. Now that she was more clear headed she knew last night had been a mistake. A mistake that shouldn't have happened, wouldn't have happened if she had been sober.
Slowly she moved out of the bed, grabbing her clothes on the way. Once she was out of his room she slipped into the bathroom, knowing she needed to take a shower before she went to pick up the kids. She didn't want to pick them up smelling of sex. Smelling like Taylor.
Laying her clothes on the back of the toilet she bent over, turning the water on, waiting for it to get just right before she stepped in, closing her eyes as she relaxed some under the water. She hated that she let Taylor get in her pants again. Hated that she slept with him knowing he was Theo's father, knowing that deep down she was still in love with Isaac. Even if she knew they'd never get back together she still had some hope and if he knew she had slept with Taylor he'd never see her the same way again.
Though Isaac did sleep with Nikki so maybe if he found out he wouldn't judge her too bad. Maybe he wouldn't be so mad at her. Maybe that was all Natalie could hope for..a bunch of fucking maybe's.
Feeling a pair of hands on her naked hips, Natalie opened her eyes seeing Taylor with her in the shower, which caused her forehead to crinkle some in confusion. Was she still asleep? She wasn't sure why he was in the shower with her nor was she sure she liked the idea of him being in the shower with her, even if the shower was in his house.
Before she can say anything though Taylor leaned in to kiss her, making her breath catch in her throat. Now that she wasn't drunk she was surprised to find that maybe being drunk had nothing to do with what happened last night. Taylor lips did feel good on her own and she let herself respond to the kiss knowing it was risky. There was no excuse for this now. No blaming the alcohol.
Kissing him harder, she moaned out as Taylor pushed her back against the wall, his lips trailing down her neck which made her tilt her head to the side, "Taylor," she muttered out as she felt his hand reach down to lift up her leg and soon she felt him slide inside of her. "This..it's wrong," she told him though she wasn't sure she could make him stop.
"But it feels good," Taylor countered once he heard Natalie's words. "Last night was amazing," he whispered on her skin as he started to move inside of her. "I just...I don't want this to end," he confessed not caring that he was engaged to Nikki.Not caring that she was divorcing his brother. "Be my dirty secret?" he asked as his lips trailed to her ear which he nibbled on. This wouldn't be the first time he had an affair while in a relationship, though it would be the first time he had one while engaged.
Natalie heard Taylor ask her to be his dirty secret and she shook her head, "W..we can't," she voiced knowing that even though they were having sex again this had to be the last time. Anyway once the truth came out about Theodore, Taylor would hate her. He'd never want her and she still had hopes that she could work things out with Isaac...even if her vagina obviously wanted another Hanson.
Closing her eyes again though she let her nails dig into Taylor's back as he continued to move inside of her, obviously not trying to change her mind on not agreeing to be his dirty secret. She was glad for that because when she finally reached her orgasm she was sure he could have won her over if he had wanted too.
When he finally came she opened her eyes, watching as he moved away from her. Natalie was just about to open her mouth when she heard his front door open.
"Taylor!" Nikki's voice called out from downstairs, which made Natalie's eyes go wide as she watched Taylor freeze for a few seconds like a deer in headlights. Thought it didn't last long before he climbed out of the shower.
"I'll be there in a second baby," Taylor called out after slipping out of the shower. As he wrapped a towel around his waist he looked at Natalie before chewing on his lip. He hated to admit that he was kind of hurt that she had rejected his offer to have an affair, though he knew that was no reason to give away that she was here but that was going to happen.
Natalie would have to leave the bathroom too and Nikki would do the math, they were both screwed no matter what now. Not even saying a word to her though, he opened the door and slipped outside, going down the stairs.
After Taylor left her alone in the bathroom, Natalie frowned but got out as well, drying and dressing quickly. She wasn't sure what she would do when she saw Nikki but in all honesty Nikki had no right being mad about this. Not when Nikki had fucked Isaac..not when she was blackmailing Isaac.
Taking a deep breath once she was ready Natalie left the bathroom and headed downstairs where she found Nikki and Taylor in the middle of an argument, Nikki's glare soon turning to her.
"You fucking whore," Nikki spat as she walked over to Natalie. She knew who the woman was, she knew she was Isaac's wife. She also knew Natalie's past thanks to Isaac, just like she knew Natalie's secret. Though Natalie didn't know hers. Natalie was oblivious to her fucking Isaac as was Taylor. Nikki loved that she could play the scorned woman card all she wanted. "Did Taylor's brother not tell you we were engaged?" she asked as she raised an eyebrow before grabbing a hold of Natalie's wrist to stop her from leaving.
Making a face when Nikki grabbed her wrist, Natalie shook her head, "No, he didn't," she lied as she eyed Nikki. "I haven't seen him in a few weeks," she lied again not even feeling bad for her lies. "But Taylor did tell me himself you guys were engaged," she snapped back.
Nikki glared as she held Natalie's wrist tighter, "Yet you still fucked him," she said before rolling her eyes.
"Well actually he fucked me too," Natalie countered ignoring the pressure added when Nikki's grip got worse. "He fucked me too and he seemed to like it so much that he had to have it again in the shower," she smirked. She knew she should be feeling guilty but she just hated Nikki. She hated Nikki for what she was doing to Isaac.
"Don't you dare play that card," Nikki sneered as she raised her free hand slapping Natalie across the face hard.
Taylor winced as Nikki slapped Natalie and he walked over to both of them, grabbing Nikki's arm and pulling her away from Natalie, "Nikki baby calm down, you really shouldn't get too worked up okay. Don't press people's buttons not in your condition."
Holding her cheek, Natalie watched as Taylor lead Nikki away. "Her condition?" she asked as she raised an eyebrow.
"She's pregnant Natalie," Taylor confessed as he looked at her a frown appearing on his lips. "That's why she came back from her trip early. She just found out she is pregnant."
Natalie swallowed hard as she heard Taylor say Nikki was pregnant. All she could do was remember the night Isaac confessed to sleeping with Nikki. Feeling her face pale some she was afraid she was going to faint in Taylor's living room so she rested her hand against a wall to steady herself.
"That's great," Natalie nodded forcing a smile as she locked eyes with Nikki. "I have to go though now," she said as she removed her hand from the wall just wanting to get out of there fast. Without another word she finally got her feet to move and she left Taylor's house making it to where she had parked her car.
Getting in she put her keys in the ignition before reaching for the cell phone she had in a cup holder. Checking it she saw a text message from Isaac telling her they needed to meet up asap. A text message that had been sent just an hour ago.
Replying back she agreed, telling Isaac to meet her at the house. After sending the text she called Diana to tell her that she'd be picking up the kids sometime in the afternoon instead of the morning as she had planned to do.
Once she had hung up from speaking with Diana, Natalie finally started her car and drove away. When she finally made it home she parked behind Isaac's car. Getting out she walked to the porch and let herself inside where she found Isaac holding the paper with the DNA test results.
Natalie swallowed hard again having forgotten that she had left the papers on the coffee table. She hadn't wanted Isaac to find out this way. She hadn't wanted Isaac to find out on accident.
"Theo isn't mine?" Isaac asked as he looked up from the paper's he held in his hand. He had just gotten here not too long ago himself. He knew he shouldn't have but he let himself in with his old key. He also knew he shouldn't have picked up the paper but he did...he did and now he knew that Theodore the son he raised since birth wasn't his. Theodore belonged to Taylor.
Natalie shook her head sadly, "No...he isn't yours," she said shutting the door before walking to Isaac. "I..I found out yesterday but I needed a day to process things. I was going to tell you but I didn't want you to find out like this."
Laying the paper down on the table Isaac nodded, "I believe you," he said before sitting on the couch and laughing bitterly. "That was the last thing I needed today though after finding out Nikki is pregnant?"
"You know Nikki is pregnant?" Natalie asked as she sat down beside Isaac on the couch. "I mean she came back from a trip today. She just told Taylor.." Natalie started but stopped herself as a blush came onto her cheeks. She had probably said too much.
"How do you know Nikki is pregnant and how do you know she just told Taylor?" Isaac questioned his wife as he locked eyes with her, realization soon hitting him square in the face when he saw the blush on her cheeks and the guilt in her eyes.Natalie was like an open book to him by now when it came to her reactions. She knew because she had been there. She knew because she had been with Taylor when he had found out.
Natalie shrugged as she looked away from Isaac's gaze, "I..I was with him," she stuttered as she ran a hand through her hair. "I may have gotten drunk with him last night. We may have had sex last night when we were drunk and then again this morning in the shower. Nikki showed up after the shower sex. We had a confrontation and it came out about her condition as Taylor called it. When I asked he told me she was pregnant."
Closing his eyes at Natalie's words Isaac hated to admit that he was jealous she had been with Taylor. It was silly for him to be jealous when Natalie would soon no longer be his wife. Natalie was free to do as she pleased but it hurt knowing it was Taylor. It hurt knowing she had slept with the man who was the real father of the son he considered his. Though then again he considered Natalie his too still.
"Nikki says the baby could be mine," Isaac revealed deciding not to say anything about Natalie sleeping with Taylor. "But she wants me to let Taylor believe it's his. Seems she wants to be just like you," he said a little too harsh.
Natalie did her best to ignore Isaac's harsh tone, "Well when I tell Taylor the truth about Theo you won't have to worry about letting Taylor believe Nikki's baby is his. You can be honest with him."
Isaac just nodded his head not sure now if telling him about Nikki was a good thing, especially since Theo wasn't his son. Maybe they could just keep letting everyone believe that Theo was his and let Taylor believe fully that Nikki's child was his. Maybe that would be best. Or maybe he was just scared that he'd lose Theo and that Nikki's baby also wouldn't be his and then he'd have no one.
Hell he was already losing Natalie if she had so easily slept with Taylor twice in just twenty-four hours.
